Is anyone else as tired of Brooke as much as I am?  She was an early favorite of mine but she to emotional. Could she really handle fame? Her time has come to go.  Winner this year - David Cook

I agree I liked her in the beginning too, but she gets on my nerves now.  I think it'll be a David... either Cook or Archulta (spl?)

BROOKE IS STIFF AS A BOARD, ENTIRELY TOO EMOTIONAL, TALENTED IN COUNTRY WESTERN ONLY.    I'M SICK OF LOOKING AT HER.  WHEN WILL THESE CONTESTANTS GET IT...STOP CHALLENGING THE JUDGES' CRITIQUES AND ARGUING BACK.  KEEP YOUR MOUTHS SHUT AND PUT ON A SMILING POKER FACE.

She get ons my nerves soooooo bad. She needs to shut up when the judges are slamming her and stop the crying. I think (hope) she is gone tonight. Go David Cook!!!