Here's how I have it this evening:

1. David Cook: Best performance of the night.

2. Syesha Mercado: 2nd best performance of the night.

3. Carly Smithson: Great voice but couldn't keep up with the music.

4. Brooke White: I think she is in serious trouble.

5. David Archulerta: I think people get confused that he is 17 and not 12 years old.

6. Jason Castro: Too much smoke, he's gone!

---

http://sportstoday.proboards58.com

I think you pretty much nailed it.  I am really fed up with Brooke and her "pity parties."  If Jason wants to stay, he needs to listen to advice and choose better songs.

I almost agree entirely.  I've wanted to see Jason out long ago.  I preferred Michael Johns.

I'm tired of Jason and Carly.  I like Brooke White, but she can't seem to cut it.  Last night I think David Cook and Syesha Mercado did the best.  David A. is too young.  He should come back again, maybe in another year or two.  He is good, but he's just not THAT good.

I don't know why the results of last night should shock anyone because until they change their format where you vote for the worse person each week these rediculous results will continue.

The bright side to last night is all of them have a future in music no matter what the results.

---

http://sportstoday.proboards58.com